research news

By KEVIN MANNE
Published November 13, 2026
Pairing patients with dedicated care coordinators reduces emergency room visits, but the benefit weakens the longer a patient stays enrolled and varies depending on their underlying health condition, according to new research from the UB School of Management.
Forthcoming in Production and Operations Management Society, the study found that patient navigation programs (which connect care coordinators with patients to help them manage chronic conditions, attend appointments and overcome logistical barriers) result in nearly 1.38 million fewer emergency room visits per year and $3.7 billion in savings, though the savings per patient fall short of what the programs cost to run.
“The real value of patient navigation programs lies in broader system efficiencies,” says study co-author Raj Sharman, professor in the Department of Management Science and Systems in the UB School of Management. “Total spending at a healthcare organization starts declining once about 20% of patients are enrolled in navigation, which suggests the program has ripple effects beyond any single patient’s ER visits.”
To measure whether patient navigators reduced ER visits, the researchers analyzed more than 340,000 observations from more than 11,000 patients enrolled in an Accountable Care Organization located in a historically underserved region of a Northeastern U.S. state characterized by significant social determinants of health challenges. Approximately 4,000 of these patients received support from a navigator.
Because patients entered the navigation program at different points in time rather than simultaneously, the researchers employed a sliding-window matching technique to pair each participant with comparable patients who did not receive navigator services. This approach enabled a more rigorous evaluation of the navigation program’s impact on ER utilization.
They then used a statistical method called staggered difference-in-differences to compare how their ER visits changed for each group before and after enrollment. Finally, they interviewed healthcare practitioners to help understand the mechanisms behind the quantitative results.
Their findings show that the longer someone stayed in the program, the smaller its benefit became — shrinking by about 10% with each extra quarter enrolled. The researchers say this may indicate that these programs are solving the most easily fixable problems early on, while patients who stay enrolled the longest tend to have more complex, harder-to-resolve health needs.
“Healthcare systems should move away from standardized navigation programs and focus on adaptive, tiered support that adjusts based on a patient’s evolving needs, allowing more support for patients who are struggling and reducing it for those who have stabilized,” says Sharman.
Sharman collaborated on the study with Jiajia Qu, assistant professor of computer information systems and business in the James Madison University College of Business; and Indranil Bardhan, professor of management information systems in the University of Texas at Austin McCombs School of Business.