Before building mental health apps, designers need to understand the problem

Study reveals guidelines for technologists working on social anxiety disorders

Hand holding a phone with a screen that reads "What is your mood today? Measure your mental state. With sad, neutral and happy face icons and a "Let's Explore" button.

Release Date: October 6, 2026

Print
Suresh.
“People tend to minimize what they are going through, disclose only fragments or reframe their situation in more acceptable terms. Designers then build tools like digital therapy services and self-guided mental health apps around a picture of the problem that was never accurate to begin with.”
University at Buffalo School of Management

BUFFALO, N.Y. — When technology designers work on the mental health issues that people tend to conceal or struggle to describe, they often end up with elegant solutions that can make problems worse, according to new research from the University at Buffalo School of Management.

Recently published in Decision Support Systems, the study explores “wicked psychosocial problems” — the painful mental disorders people hide — to uncover how scientists can get to the root of problems like social anxiety and loneliness before developing technical solutions. 

“Stigma, shame and fear of being judged keep the real problems out of view,” says study co-author Joana Gaia, PhD, clinical assistant professor of management science and systems in the UB School of Management. “People tend to minimize what they are going through, disclose only fragments or reframe their situation in more acceptable terms. Designers then build tools like digital therapy services and self-guided mental health apps around a picture of the problem that was never accurate to begin with.”

The researchers compared two independent design science projects to examine how each team figured out what each problem was. The first used topic modeling and hand-coding to analyze more than 6,000 anonymous forum posts that explored social anxiety disorder among adults. The second used staff interviews, call observations and workshops to study loneliness among older adults who called a service center repeatedly without ever saying they are lonely. 

Their findings revealed that the people with social anxiety weren’t getting help because they were worried about being judged, not because help was hard to find. And for the older adults who were lonely, the problem was that despite the workers being able to tell that the callers were lonely, there was no official way for them to say so or do anything about it.

From these two projects, the researchers uncovered seven rules for anyone designing services or technology around a sensitive problem:

  1. Stay flexible about how you investigate rather than locking in one method at the start. 
  2. Slow down when early findings feel thin and build that pause into the schedule. 
  3. Move back and forth between individual stories and the bigger patterns instead of picking one. 
  4. When accounts contradict each other, treat that as information rather than a mess to clean up. 
  5. Bring the people closest to the problem in as partners who help interpret what’s going on, not just as sources to collect from. 
  6. Hold off on committing to a solution while the picture is still forming. 
  7. And when a finding feels especially satisfying or convenient, check it against other evidence before acting on it.

“When people have good reasons to keep something hidden the real work is in understanding the problem,” says study co-author Raj Sharman, professor of management science and systems in the UB School of Management. “A well-built solution aimed at the wrong problem is a waste of effort that can leave people feeling more exposed than before.”

Gaia and Sharman collaborated on the study with UB School of Management PhD graduate and lead author Pavankumar Mulgund from the University of Memphis; Shannon Colville, Nadine Ostern, Wasana Bandara and Sophie Coulton from the Queensland University of Technology; Sandeep Purao from Bentley University; Lavlin Agrawal from North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University; and Catherine Haslam from the University of Queensland.

The UB School of Management is recognized for its emphasis on real-world learning, community and impact, and the global perspective of its faculty, students and alumni. In addition, the school has been ranked by Bloomberg Businessweek, Entrepreneur, Financial Times, Forbes and U.S. News & World Report for the quality of its programs and the return on investment it provides its graduates. For more information about the UB School of Management, visit management.buffalo.edu.

Media Contact Information

Contact
Kevin Manne
Associate Director of Communications
School of Management
716-645-5238
kjmanne@buffalo.edu