Published April 5, 2013
Earth’s exponentially growing population is a “wicked problem” at the root of every major issue plaguing Earth today, Sonny Ramaswamy, director of the National Institute of Food and Agriculture, said at a thought-provoking presentation March 6 in the Center for the Arts.
Ramaswamy used the term “wicked problem,” coined in 1973 by German industrial engineer Horace Rittel, to describe a predicament where the path to progress is blocked because superficial disagreements or political infighting prevent the best technology available from coming to the rescue.
Earth’s population hit 7 billion on Halloween night last October, and it is on a trajectory to surpass 9 billion by the year 2050, according to Ramaswamy. Unless research leads to new discoveries to increase food production, current land and water constraints mean that sustaining a population of 9 billion would require two additional Earths.
Agricultural competitiveness—or making farms more
efficient—is another problem adding to our inability to feed
the planet, according to Ramaswamy. The average age of the American
farmer is 60 years old, according to a recent census.
Issues such as poverty, energy, water and health can be met head
on by reforming our food system and improving our agricultural
competitiveness,. Ramaswamy said.
Ramaswamy laid out the four challenges we must solve to create enough food for the world’s population without wreaking havoc on the environment: overcoming “biotic and abiotic” constraints, reducing food waste, improving our farming system and enacting sensible governmental policies.
One example of a biotic constraint is the lack of diversity in our food. Although there are 50,000 edible plant species, we are only eating between 15 and 50 of them. For example, research could find ways to grow and harvest other crops besides corn, wheat and rice that could feed large numbers of people.
Ramaswamy said solutions must come from taking an interdisciplinary approach and “crowdsourcing” ideas, a concept that encourages experts from many different backgrounds to work together to find a “game-changing” or “transformative” approach.
Organized by UB’s Office of the Vice President for Research and Economic Development, the title of Ramaswamy’s talk, “Setting the Table for a Flatter, Hotter, More Crowded Earth,” is inspired by Thomas Friedman’s 2005 bestseller “The World is Flat,” which argues that globalization in the 21st century is driven by technological advances.
Ramaswamy's message about the need for "taking an interdisciplinary approach and "crowdsourcing" ideas, a concept that encourages experts from many different backgrounds to work together to find a "game-changing" or "transformative" approach is absolutely true.
But it is just wishful thinking unless we can match this imperative with a process of collaboration that can deliver. We know that parliamentary practice and partisan politics doesn't, neither do conferences, social media or prescriptions from economists or any other particular group or class. For a variety of reasons.
But there is one process which, by design, has the capability of supporting strong, rich, deliberative conversations and collaboration. It delivers a multifaceted strategy where each facet addresses an aspect of the "wicked" problem while being integrated with the other facets to ensure no overlaps, contradictions or gaps. The development of the strategy is consent-based, so objections are surfaced early and integrated into the solution design. This consent-based approach fosters a critical mass of persons fully committed to making the deployment of the strategy a success.
This process is called e-Deliberation.